top of page
Search

Accident-Damaged Vans in Manchester: Should You Repair or Replace?

van repair manchester

The £3,000 Question: Should You Repair or Replace Your Van?


It’s the call no fleet manager wants to make, but every one eventually has to.

One of your vans gets hit. The quote comes back: £3,200. The van’s market value? Maybe £4,500. Insurance is hinting at a write-off. You need that van back on the road now, but you're staring at numbers that don’t make sense.


Sound familiar?


You’re not alone. We’ve helped over 150 Manchester fleet managers work through this exact scenario, and here’s what we’ve learned: the repair vs replace decision isn’t just financial, it’s operational. And most advice out there oversimplifies it.

So let’s walk through the real questions you should be asking before you give that green light to the body shop, or start hunting for a replacement van.


Why Repair Quotes Are Just the Starting Point for Van Repair Manchester

That £3,200 figure is rarely the full picture.


What most quotes leave out:

  • Hidden damage that only shows up once panels are removed (often adding 15–30%)

  • The cost of hiring a temporary van for a week or two

  • Lost income during downtime

  • Reduced resale value, even after a perfect repair


Now flip it. Replacing the van brings its own hidden costs:

  • Time lost sourcing a decent van (often 2–4 weeks in Manchester)

  • The cost of fitting racking, decals, refrigeration units, and other modifications

  • Insurance or financing complications

  • Onboarding for drivers used to your current fleet setup


The headline numbers are easy. But what really matters is: which choice keeps your fleet productive, your cash flow healthy, and your customers happy?


What the Manchester Market Tells Us

Here’s how we typically break it down based on current market conditions:

Vans under 5 years old are usually worth repairing, unless there’s serious structural damage. They hold their value well and are often more expensive to replace than repair.


Vans between 5 and 8 years old need a closer look. Mileage, overall condition, and any specialist equipment play a big role. One well-maintained, fully fitted 2017 Sprinter might be worth repairing at 70% of its value. Another one? Not even close.


Vans over 8 years old with 100k+ miles and general wear? Unless it’s got major modifications, replacement is almost always more cost-effective in the long run.

And then there are specialist vehicles, refrigerated vans, vans with tail lifts, or custom setups. These are almost always worth repairing, even at a higher percentage of the vehicle's value.


What About Insurance?

Insurers use simple math: if the repair costs more than 60–70% of your van’s market value, it’s declared a total loss. But here’s what they don’t consider:


  • Your business’s unique use of that van

  • The cost and time of sourcing a replacement

  • Any modifications they don’t value, but you still need

  • Downtime disruption to your schedule and customer service


You’re allowed to challenge their decision, and you should if you believe it’s based on outdated or incomplete information. We've helped clients:


  • Get higher valuations using independent assessors

  • Buy their own vans back as salvage

  • Repair at lower, out-of-network costs and pocket the difference


The key is knowing your numbers, and having a repair partner who’ll give you real cost breakdowns, not optimistic estimates.


What Do We Recommend? Our Framework for Fleet Decisions

We work through four key areas with every fleet client facing this dilemma:


  1. True Repair CostIncluding the quote, hire van, potential add-ons, and downtime.

  2. True Replacement CostPurchase price, setup, MOT, graphics, equipment refit, and delivery delays.

  3. Operational ImpactCan you afford the downtime? Do you have backup vans? Will replacing disrupt your routes or customers?

  4. Value TrajectoryWill this van serve you another 18–24 months post-repair? Or are you putting off the inevitable?


When we run those numbers, the right answer usually reveals itself.


Real Cases We’ve Handled in Manchester

Case: 2019 Ford Transit Custom

Damage: Side impact, moderate panel work

Repair quote: £2,800

Value: £12,000

✅ Repaired. Quick turnaround. Van back in service in five days.


Case: 2017 Mercedes Sprinter (Fridge Unit)

Damage: Rear-end collision + structural work

Repair quote: £4,200

Value: £6,500

✅ Repaired. Fridge unit was worth £3,000 alone. A new van with the same spec would have cost £20k+.


Case: 2015 Vauxhall Vivaro

Damage: Front-end collision

Repair quote: £3,100

Value: £4,200

❌Replaced. Van had 150k miles and ongoing mechanical issues. It was time.


Final Thought: It’s Not Just the Van - It’s the Business Around It

Choosing whether to repair or replace your van isn't just a numbers game. It's about keeping your operation moving, your customers satisfied, and your costs predictable.

We’re not just here to take on repair work, we’re here to help you make the right business call. Even if that means telling you, honestly, “You’re better off replacing.”


Need a Straight Answer?

Contact Revive & Drive for an honest, pressure-free assessment. We’ll run the numbers with you, look at the bigger picture, and help you decide what actually makes sense — not just what makes us money.


Let’s figure it out together. Call now for advice that puts your fleet first.



 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page